Skip to content
East Valley (480) 571-5944 · Northern AZ (928) 813-0825 · Open 24 hours, seven days. $300 off tankless water heater installation → · Finance now →

Evaluate · Learning Center

Trenchless Sewer Repair vs. Dig and Replace: How to Choose

What each method does, what the camera looks for, and the pipe conditions that point to lining or to digging.

Step 02 · Evaluate · 4 min read

By Mike Smith , Owner, Gold Star Plumbing & Drain · LinkedIn

Hearing that your sewer line needs repair usually brings one picture to mind: a trench across the front yard. Sometimes that is still the right answer. Often there is another option that fixes the pipe from the inside.

Here is how trenchless repair and traditional excavation compare, and how a camera inspection decides which one your line can actually use.

What is the difference between trenchless repair and dig and replace?

Trenchless repair fixes the pipe from the inside through small access points. Dig and replace opens a trench so the damaged pipe can be removed and new pipe laid in.

Trenchless lining feeds a resin-soaked liner into the old pipe and cures it in place, forming a new, seamless pipe inside the old one. The work happens through a cleanout or a small access pit, so most of the yard stays as it was.

Dig and replace is the traditional method: excavate down to the pipe, cut out the damaged section, lay new pipe at the correct slope, and backfill. Between the two sits a sewer spot repair, which digs only where one section has failed.

How does a camera inspection decide it?

The camera shows the pipe's shape, the type of damage and where along the line it sits, and those facts decide which methods can work.

A sewer camera inspection travels the line and records what is inside: cracks, roots at the joints, offset joints, low spots holding water, or a section that has collapsed. Our guide to sewer camera inspections explains what the footage shows.

The line often has to be cleaned first, sometimes with hydro jetting, so the camera and any liner have clean pipe to work with. This guide picks up where our drain cleaning methods guide leaves off: once the camera shows damage rather than a simple clog.

When does trenchless lining fit?

When the pipe still holds its shape and slope: cracks, roots at the joints, corrosion and leaking joints along a line that is still round and draining in the right direction.

A cured liner has no joints along its length, and joints are where roots usually find their way in. Because it goes in through small access points, lining can avoid tearing up driveways, pavers, desert landscaping and other features many Arizona yards are built around.

Our trenchless sewer repair page covers how the work is done and what to expect on the day.

When is digging the better answer?

When the pipe has collapsed, sags enough to hold water, has badly offset joints, or needs its slope corrected, because a liner follows the shape of the pipe it is placed in.

A liner cannot fix a belly in the line. If a section has settled and holds water, lining it leaves the low spot in place, and waste keeps collecting there. A collapsed pipe may not leave room for a liner at all.

In those cases, excavation and underground repair lets the plumber remove the bad pipe and lay new pipe at the correct slope. When the whole line is failing, full sewer line replacement may be the long-term answer.

How do I weigh the options once I have the footage?

Ask the plumber to show you the damage, explain which methods could work on your line, and lay out each option with its warranty.

Gold Star offers Three Clear Options. No Pressure. Whenever possible, you will see more than one way forward, with the benefits and warranty coverage of each explained before you choose. Sewer work often needs a permit and an inspection, which an honest plan includes from the start.

Sewer repairs can be a big expense, and Financing Options Available through GreenSky can help. Our guide to financing vs. paying cash walks through that decision.

Quick answers

Does trenchless mean no digging at all?
Usually it means very little. The work is done through an existing cleanout or a small access pit rather than a trench along the whole line.
Will lining make my pipe smaller?
A liner takes up a little room inside the pipe. On a sound residential line, the plumber will confirm it still drains properly before recommending it.
Can roots grow back through a liner?
A cured liner has no joints along its length, and joints are where roots usually get in. That is one of the main reasons lining is used on root-damaged lines.

Next step

Repeat backups or a bad camera report? Start with an inspection and see which repair your line can actually use.

Sewer line services

More in weigh your options

All guides →
  1. Repair or Replace Your Water Heater? An Honest Framework The three questions — age, anode, tank — that decide it, and how a plumber weighs each one. 5 min
  2. Tank vs. Tankless Water Heaters in Arizona: A Fair Look What each one does well, and how hard water and gas sizing change the answer here. 5 min
  3. Snake, Hydro Jetting or Camera First? Drains Compared Three tools, three different jobs — and why the camera often decides between the other two. 5 min
  4. Plumbing Brands: How to Judge Heaters, Toilets and Faucets The four things that separate one brand from another once it is on your wall, and the brands Gold Star installs. 4 min
  5. DIY or Call a Plumber? What Homeowners Can Safely Handle The small jobs worth doing yourself, the signs a DIY fix has gone far enough, and the work that always belongs to a licensed plumber. 4 min
  6. Financing vs. Paying Cash for Big Plumbing Jobs in Arizona When financing a big repair makes sense, what paying cash really trades away, and the questions to ask before you sign. 3 min
  7. Copper vs. PEX vs. PVC Pipe: What Works in Arizona Homes Supply pipe versus drain pipe, what copper and PEX-A each do well, and where PVC and ABS belong. 4 min
  8. What Drives the Cost of a Plumbing Job in Arizona? The five things that move a plumbing price up or down, and how Gold Star's upfront pricing works. 3 min
  9. When a Second Opinion on Plumbing Work Is Worth Getting When a second look pays off, what to have ready, and how to compare two opinions fairly. 3 min
  10. After-Hours Plumber or Wait Until Morning? How to Decide The problems that justify an after-hours call, the ones that can wait for a regular appointment, and three questions to decide. 3 min
Call now Book online