Step 01 · Learn · 5 min read
By Mike Smith
, Owner, Gold Star Plumbing & Drain ·
LinkedIn
When a water heater fails, most people replace it with whatever was there before. That is often the right call, but it helps to know the other types exist, because a replacement is the one moment you can change what you have.
This guide explains how each main type works. When you are ready to weigh the two most common choices against each other, our tank vs. tankless guide takes it from there.
How does a standard tank water heater work?
It stores a tank of water and keeps it hot all day, so hot water is ready the moment you open a tap, until the tank runs low.
A tank heater fills with cold water at the bottom and sends hot water out the top. A thermostat turns the heat on whenever the stored water cools, even overnight when no one is using it. That standing reheat is the main energy trade-off of a tank. When a big demand empties the tank, you wait while the next batch heats.
Tanks come in two fuel types. A gas tank heats with a burner under the tank and sends its exhaust out through a flue. An electric tank uses heating elements inside the water and needs no venting. Gas tanks usually recover sooner after a big draw, while electric tanks are simpler to place. For tank-style heaters, Gold Star installs Bradford White. Every tank also carries an anode rod that protects the steel from rust.
What makes a tankless water heater different?
It has no tank. It heats water only while water flows through it, so it does not run out, but it can only heat so many gallons per minute at once.
When you open a hot tap, the unit senses the flow and fires a powerful burner or element that heats the water as it passes through a heat exchanger. There is no stored water and no standby reheating. The unit hangs on a wall, which frees up the floor space a tank used to take.
The limit is flow, not volume. Open enough hot taps at the same time and the unit splits its output between them. Gas tankless units also need a larger gas supply and their own venting, and in Arizona the heat exchanger needs regular descaling. For tankless, Gold Star installs Navien. Our tankless water heater page covers installation and upkeep.
What is a heat-pump or hybrid water heater?
It is an electric tank that pulls heat out of the surrounding air and moves it into the water, falling back on a standard element when demand runs high.
A heat-pump water heater works like a refrigerator in reverse. A small compressor on top of the tank draws warmth from the air around it and moves that warmth into the water. Moving heat takes less electricity than making it, so a heat pump can heat water with much less power than a standard electric element. Most models are called hybrids because they keep a regular element as a backup for heavy use.
Location matters with this type. The unit needs open air around it, it cools and dries the space it sits in, and it works most efficiently in a warm room. A Phoenix-area garage suits it for much of the year, while a cold garage in the high country makes it lean on its backup element more in winter. See heat-pump and hybrid water heaters for what an install involves.
What does a recirculation system do?
It is not a water heater. It is an add-on that keeps hot water moving toward your fixtures, so it reaches the tap much sooner instead of after a long wait.
In a larger house, or one where the water heater sits at the far end of the garage, you can run the shower for a long time before hot water arrives. All that cold water goes down the drain. A recirculation system uses a small pump, and sometimes a dedicated return line, to send cooled water back to the heater so hot water is waiting near the fixtures.
Systems can run on a timer, on demand from a button or sensor, or based on temperature. They can work with both tank and tankless heaters, though a tankless pairing needs a compatible unit or setup. Our recirculation systems page explains the choices.
How do I know which type fits my house?
Start from what you have: your fuel, your space, your household's hot water habits and your water quality. Those four facts narrow the list.
Gas availability decides a lot. Without a gas line, the choice is usually an electric tank, electric tankless or a heat-pump hybrid. Space matters too: tankless frees floor space, while a hybrid needs more room around it than a standard tank. Then there is how your household uses hot water: several showers back to back, a big soaking tub, or light use spread through the day.
Water quality is the Arizona factor every type shares. Hard water shortens the life of tanks and tankless units alike, which is why how long a water heater lasts here is worth reading before you choose. When you are ready to talk about your house, our water heater team works the same way on every job: Three Clear Options. No Pressure.
Quick answers
- Do tankless heaters work in Northern Arizona?
- Yes. Colder incoming water in winter means the unit has to raise the temperature further, which lowers how many gallons per minute it can deliver at once. Sizing for winter water temperature in places like Flagstaff and Prescott is part of choosing the right unit.
- Can I switch from gas to electric, or the other way?
- Often, yes, but it changes more than the heater. Going to gas means a gas line and venting. Going to electric may mean the home needs a circuit sized for the new unit, which is work for an electrician. Talk it through at the house before deciding.
- Which type lasts the longest?
- No type is immune to hard water. A maintained tank and a maintained tankless unit can both give long service. Maintenance and water quality usually matter more than the type.
Next step
Water heater services