Skip to content
East Valley (480) 571-5944 · Northern AZ (928) 813-0825 · Open 24 hours, seven days. $300 off tankless water heater installation → · Finance now →

Symptom Center

Toilet Keeps Running or a Faucet Drips? Causes and Fixes

Small, but it wastes water every hour, and repeat failures often point to high water pressure.

Book ahead Small, but a running toilet or dripping faucet wastes water around the clock and rarely fixes itself.

Book Online

Symptom Center · 4 min read

By Mike Smith , Owner, Gold Star Plumbing & Drain · LinkedIn

A toilet that refills on its own every so often, hisses all night, or runs until you jiggle the handle is wasting water every hour it goes on. So is a faucet that will not quite shut off. Neither is an emergency, but both show up on the water bill.

Most of the time the fix is a worn part. Sometimes the real cause is water pressure higher than the fixtures were built for, and that is worth knowing, because it is why parts keep failing.

Why does my toilet keep running?

Usually a worn flapper, a fill valve out of adjustment, or a lift chain that is too short or tangled.

The flapper is the rubber seal at the bottom of the tank. When it wears, warps or collects scale, water leaks into the bowl, and the tank refills to replace it. That is the short hiss or refill you hear when nobody has flushed. The fill valve controls how high the tank fills. If it is set too high, water spills into the overflow tube and the toilet runs nonstop.

Hard water speeds all of this up. Scale on the flapper seat keeps it from sealing, and scale in the fill valve makes it stick. Faucets fail the same way, when scale grinds at the cartridge or seat until it no longer shuts off completely.

  • A worn or warped flapper
  • A fill valve set too high, or sticking
  • A lift chain that is too short, too long or tangled
  • A failed cartridge or worn seat in a dripping faucet
  • Water pressure above what the fixtures were built for

What can I safely try myself?

Check the chain and the water level, test the flapper with food coloring, and close the toilet's supply valve between flushes if it will not stop.

Lift the tank lid and look. If the chain is caught under the flapper, free it. If water is running into the overflow tube, the fill level is too high, and many fill valves have an adjustment screw or clip to lower it.

To test the flapper, put a few drops of food coloring in the tank and wait about fifteen minutes without flushing. If color shows up in the bowl, the flapper is leaking. If the toilet will not stop running at all, close the small supply valve behind it and open it only to refill after each flush until it is repaired.

Replacing a flapper is a reasonable homeowner job. If the valves are stiff, the parts do not match, or the tank is cracked, it is time to call. Our guide to DIY vs. calling a plumber covers where that line sits.

What does the plumber check first?

We repair the fixture, and check static pressure at the hose bib, because high pressure is often the reason parts keep failing.

We find which part has failed and replace it, then make sure the toilet or faucet shuts off fully. We also check the shutoff valve under the fixture, since a valve that has not been turned in years can be scaled stiff.

Then we check static water pressure at an outdoor hose bib. Plumbing codes commonly set a maximum for household water pressure, and many homes have a pressure-reducing valve to stay under it. When that valve fails, pressure climbs and fixtures wear out sooner. If one toilet or faucet keeps eating parts, high pressure is often the reason.

Should I repair or replace the fixture?

Repair it when the parts are available and the fixture is sound. Replace it when it is cracked, worn out, or has needed repeated repairs.

Most running toilets and dripping faucets are fixed with a part, through our toilet repair or faucet and fixture repair services. When a toilet is cracked, rocks on the floor or keeps clogging, toilet replacement is often the better choice. Gold Star installs TOTO and Gerber toilets, and faucets from Kohler, Delta, Moen and other brands.

If a failed pressure-reducing valve is behind the repeat failures, replacing it protects every fixture in the house. The yearly whole-home plumbing inspections in a Gold Star membership are one way to catch a failing valve before it costs you parts.

Quick answers

How much water can a running toilet waste?
It depends on the leak. A slow flapper leak wastes a little at a time, while a toilet running nonstop into the overflow tube wastes far more. Either way, it is water you pay for and never use.
My toilet refills by itself every so often. Why?
That is often called a phantom flush. Water slowly leaks from the tank into the bowl until the fill valve turns on to top it up. A new flapper usually fixes it.
Can high water pressure damage more than my toilet?
Yes. High pressure strains faucets, supply lines, the water heater and appliance hoses. If parts keep failing, a pressure check is worth asking for.

Next step

Toilet still running? Book a repair, and ask for a pressure check so the new part lasts.

Toilet repair
Call now Book online