Symptom Center · 4 min read
By Mike Smith
, Owner, Gold Star Plumbing & Drain ·
LinkedIn
Water that comes out brown, smells like rotten eggs or tastes like a swimming pool gets noticed right away. The good news is that each of these has a short list of likely causes, and a few simple observations narrow them down before anyone tests anything.
The key questions are which taps, hot or cold, and when it started. Here is how to read the answers, and when it is time for a test.
Why is my water brown or rusty?
If it is hot and cold at every tap, it is often sediment stirred up in the utility's main. If it is only the hot water, the water heater tank is the likely source.
Utility crews flush hydrants and repair mains, and both can stir up sediment that reaches your taps as brown or yellow water. That usually clears after running the cold tap for a few minutes. If the neighbors are seeing it too, check with the utility.
Rusty water from the hot side only points to the water heater. Once a tank's anode rod is used up, the steel inside starts to corrode, and the rust shows up in the hot water. Our anode rod guide explains why. Rusty water from one area of the house on both hot and cold can mean older galvanized steel pipe corroding from the inside.
- Hot and cold, every tap, sudden: often utility work stirring up sediment
- Hot side only: likely the water heater tank
- One area of the house, hot and cold: possibly corroding galvanized pipe
- Brown water that does not clear: worth a test and a look
Why does my hot water smell like rotten eggs?
Usually a reaction between bacteria in the water and the anode rod in the water heater, which makes a sulfur smell in the hot water only.
Some water carries bacteria that react with the metal in a water heater's anode rod and produce hydrogen sulfide, a gas that smells like rotten eggs. The smell tends to be strongest in hot water that has sat in the tank for a while, such as first thing in the morning or after a trip.
If the smell is in both hot and cold water, the source is more likely the water supply itself, which a water test can confirm. For a smell in the hot water only, the usual fix is swapping the anode rod for a different type and treating the tank, which is a repair, not a new heater.
One safety note: if the smell is in the air rather than in the water, and especially near a gas appliance, treat it as a possible gas leak. Leave the house and call the gas utility from outside. Our gas smell page explains what to do.
Why does my water taste like chlorine?
Utilities add chlorine or chloramine to disinfect city water. The taste is common, and carbon filtration removes it well.
Disinfection keeps city water safe on its way to your house, so some chlorine taste or smell is normal. It can be stronger at certain times of year or after the utility adjusts its treatment.
If the taste bothers you, carbon filtration is the usual fix, either for the whole house or at the kitchen sink. A reverse osmosis system goes further for drinking and cooking water.
What does a water test check, and what are the fixes?
A test measures what is in your water so the fix matches the problem. Free In-Home Water Testing—Always.
A plumber tests your water at the house, looks at the water heater and any pipe that is exposed, and explains the results. You can book through our free water testing page. If the cause is the water heater, our water heater repair team handles the anode and the tank. If it is corroded pipe, repiping may be the lasting fix.
For taste, odor and other contaminants, whole-home filtration and drinking-water systems are custom-built for Gold Star by Wood Brothers Industries. Three Clear Options. No Pressure. You choose what fits your home and budget.
Quick answers
- Is brown water safe to drink?
- Do not drink it until you know the cause. Sediment from utility work usually clears on its own, but water that stays discolored should be tested. Use bottled water in the meantime if you are unsure.
- Should I flush my water heater if the hot water smells?
- Flushing can help, but it usually does not solve the smell on its own, because the reaction happens at the anode rod. Swapping the rod type is the usual fix.
- Will a water softener fix discolored water?
- A softener treats hardness, not rust or sediment. Discolored water needs its cause found first, and the fix may be filtration, a water heater repair or new pipe.
Next step
Free water testing