Symptom Center · 4 min read
By Mike Smith
, Owner, Gold Star Plumbing & Drain ·
LinkedIn
Water heaters are not silent machines. They tick as they warm up and hum as they run. But a new sound, or one that keeps getting louder, is usually the heater telling you something.
Here is what the common sounds usually mean, which ones can wait for a maintenance visit, and the one that should not wait.
What do popping and rumbling sounds mean?
Sediment. Hard water leaves a layer of minerals on the bottom of the tank, and water trapped under it boils and pops as the burner heats it.
On a gas heater, the burner sits under the tank bottom. When sediment covers that bottom, small pockets of water get trapped and flash to steam, which makes the popping and rumbling. Electric heaters can do the same around the lower element. Our hard water guide explains why Arizona tanks build sediment so steadily.
The noise itself is not dangerous, but the sediment makes the heater work harder, cuts into the hot water you get, and over time can shorten the tank's life. A flush removes loose sediment. On a tank that has rumbled for years, the sediment may be too hardened to flush out fully.
What about ticking, humming or screeching?
Ticking is usually pipes expanding as they heat, humming can be a loose element, and a screech or whistle usually means a partly closed valve.
Ticking or tapping often comes from the pipes on top of the heater expanding and contracting as hot water moves through them, or from small check valves called heat traps. It is usually harmless. A hum on an electric heater can come from a loose heating element vibrating in the water.
A high-pitched screech or whistle often means water is being forced through a valve that is partly closed, such as the cold supply valve on top of the tank. Check that it is fully open. If the sound continues, have it looked at.
- Popping or rumbling: sediment on the tank bottom
- Ticking or tapping: pipes expanding, or heat traps
- Humming: a loose element on an electric heater
- Screeching or whistling: a partly closed or failing valve
- Hissing or sizzling: water on the burner or a relief valve releasing, which needs attention
When is a hissing sound a safety concern?
When it comes from the temperature and pressure relief valve, or from water dripping onto a gas burner. Both need attention today.
The temperature and pressure relief valve is a safety device on the side or top of the tank, with a pipe running down toward the floor. It opens to release water when the tank gets too hot or the pressure gets too high. If it is hissing, dripping or discharging, either something else is wrong and the valve is doing its job, or the valve has worn out. Either way, it needs a plumber.
Never cap, plug or block the relief valve or its pipe. It is there to keep the tank from building dangerous pressure. Stay clear of the discharge, because the water can scald. If water is pooling, shut the cold supply valve on top of the heater and turn off the gas or the breaker, then see our page on a leaking water heater.
A sizzle on a gas heater can be water dripping onto the burner. Sometimes that is normal condensation while cold water fills the tank. If it does not stop once the tank heats up, or you see water under the heater, treat it as a leak.
What does the plumber check, and what are the fixes?
We flush the tank and look at the sediment, test the relief valve, check the water pressure and temperature setting, and look at the tank's age and anode rod.
For popping and rumbling, a flush is the usual first step, and our water heater maintenance visit covers it along with an anode check. For a relief valve that opens, we check the temperature setting and the water pressure, and whether the home needs a thermal expansion tank, which absorbs the extra pressure that heating water creates.
When a tank is old and full of hardened sediment, maintenance can only do so much, and our repair or replace framework helps you decide what comes next. A Gold Star membership includes yearly water heater maintenance, which helps keep sediment from building up in the first place.
Quick answers
- Is a noisy water heater going to explode?
- Popping and rumbling from sediment is not a sign of that. The relief valve is the safety device that prevents dangerous pressure, which is why a hissing or discharging relief valve needs attention and should never be blocked.
- How often should a tank be flushed in Arizona?
- Once a year is a common recommendation in hard-water areas. A tank that already rumbles, or a home with very hard water, may benefit from more frequent service.
- Do tankless water heaters make noise?
- They can. Fans and burners make normal operating sounds, but scale in the heat exchanger can cause new noises and error codes. Tankless units here need regular descaling.
Next step
Water heater maintenance